|   SITE INDEX  |   NEWS   Search


IOM President Outlines 8 Distortions in Medicine

Date: 01-11-2012

[MMA News Now, Nov. 1, 2012] Harvey Fineberg, M.D., Ph.D., president of the Institute of Medicine, detailed what he calls eight key distortions in U.S. health care to a group of more than 100 physicians and hospital administrators at the Minneapolis Institute of Arts on Oct. 29.

“If we want a health care system that will be something that we can proudly describe and present in any part of the world we are going to have to contend with at least eight key distortions,” he said.

These distortions include:
1. An under-investment in prevention and wellness relative to what is spent on restorative treatment and care.
2. Inappropriate use, be it over-, under- or misuse of care. 
3. Misaligned incentives for all stakeholders. With this, he focused on the preponderance of fee-for-service rather than being compensated for results.
4. The failure to optimize the flow and transition of patients. He noted that we have many systems in health care but are not making the most of them.
5. A mismatch of complexity and volume of information to our capacity to manage and utilize it. In other words, getting the right information to the right people (decision makers) at the right time.
6. The increasing amount of patients seeking services and the misdistribution of health care workers (both types and geography). As an example, he talked about the increased number of new people obtaining insurance and the burden they will place on the workforce.
7. Substandard systems and processes that don’t ensure quality and safety for patients. He complimented the state of Minnesota for its leadership in quality measurement.
8. The traditional value in medicine placed on autonomy and independence. Physicians need to accept that they work on teams, he said. 

“Each of these problems has embedded in them the kernel of the solution,” Fineberg said. While he didn’t spell out specific solutions he advised those in attendance not to “wait for Uncle Sam” to fix things, work together and always keep health care patient-centric.

Fineberg’s appearance was made possible through The George Family Foundation, the Penny George Institute for Health and Healing at Allina Health, the Institute for Clinical Systems Improvement and the Twin Cities Medical Society.

Author: Dan Hauser
 
 
 
Related Articles
 
Comments
Comments (4)

Dave Dvorak, MD

7 months ago

Physician


I respectfully but profoundly disagree with Dr. Kurisko's assessment. Expecting patients to pay out-of-pocket for "most medical care most of the time" might seem reasonable for the wealthy. But, certainly for the working poor and the middle class, this inevitably leads to forgoing needed care, e.g., sitting at home for a couple days to see if the belly pain goes away, only to have the appy rupture. I suspect that many of us have seen this phenomenon in our patients more and more with the increasing prevalence of high-deductible plans. Dr. Kurisko's quick dismissal of Canadian health care ignores the fact that our neighbors to the north provide coverage to *every* citizen, meanwhile achieving equal or superior health outcomes at half the cost. The free market works great for discretionary purchases of plane tickets and flat-screen televisions, but fails completely when it comes to access to needed but unaffordable health care. Ours is by far the most free-market-based health system amongst wealthy democracies. And yet...we alone lack universal coverage (an embarrassing 50million uninsured); we pay twice as much per capita for our health care; health care costs are by far the leading cause of family bankruptcy in the US. Moving to a single-payer, improved Medicare for all health system in Minnesota would cover *all* Minnesotans, save the state $4 billion a year in health care, save the average Minnesota family $1,200 a year, and save the average MN business $1,200/year per employee (Lewin Group analysis, 2012). Any MMA members interested in becoming involved in the single payer movement and joining nearly 1,000 like-minded providers in MN alone, please consider joining the MN chapter of Physicians for a National Health Program (pnhpminnesota.org).

Lee Kurisko MD

7 months ago

Physician


Dr. Fineberg's comments imply that we need more centralized planning and control of health care than we do now. I disagree. Centralized planning of resources is a completely failed concept. For example, see Canadian health care and the economies of communist countries. What we need is a marketplace for medical services in which patients pay for most medical care themselves most of the time.


Page 1 of 2 1  2 
Add comment
Title:
   
Email:
   
Name:
   
Comment:
 
Save



Print this Page
Bookmark and Share

MMIC Litigation
1300 Godward St. NE, Suite 2500, Minneapolis, MN 55413 | Phone: (612) 378-1875 | Fax: (612) 378-3875 | mma@mnmed.org
Copyright 2013 Minnesota Medical Association
Find MMA on:                 
Home |  Membership |  About MMA |  Legislation |  Key Issues |  Publications |  Events and Services |  Site Map |  Contact Us |  Advertising |  Privacy .